Why this negotiation is different

A counteroffer situation involves negotiating with two employers at once, your current one suddenly offering more to keep you, and the new company that made you an offer in the first place, which means the decision is rarely just about the number. Data on counteroffers consistently shows a significant share of people who accept them end up leaving within a year or two anyway, often because the underlying reasons for job searching (growth ceiling, management issues, culture) weren't actually solved by a pay bump. If you're genuinely torn, it's worth being honest with yourself about whether more money fixes the real reason you started looking, or just delays the same conversation.

A specific script and approach

If you've decided to stay and want to negotiate the counteroffer itself: "I appreciate this offer and I'm considering it seriously. Beyond the salary, I'd like to understand what's changing about [the specific issue that made you look elsewhere, growth path, workload, team], since that matters as much to me as the number." If you've decided to leave despite the counteroffer: "I've decided to accept the other offer. I appreciate you making this counteroffer and I want to leave on good terms." Keep this brief and firm rather than over-explaining, which can invite more pressure to stay.

Common mistakes

Don't use a competing offer purely as leverage to get a raise with no real intention of leaving, if your manager senses this later, even a successful counteroffer negotiation can damage trust. Don't accept a counteroffer solely because the number is bigger without addressing the non-salary reasons you started looking, since those tend to resurface. And don't feel obligated to give your current employer a chance to counter if you've already made your decision, it's not owed, and dragging it out helps no one.

Get real-time help in your next interview
Live Interview Help listens to your interview and surfaces personalised answers in real time. Free 20-minute trial on Google Meet, Teams, and Zoom.
Install Free on Chrome
Check your CV against the job description first
Free AI-powered CV Match Check scores your CV against any job description: missing keywords, weak impact metrics, and ATS parsing risk, before you even apply.
Check My CV Free

Frequently asked questions

Is it true that accepting a counteroffer often backfires long term?
It's a well-documented pattern: many employees who accept a counteroffer end up leaving within the following year or two, often because the counteroffer solved the pay gap but not the underlying reason (growth, management, culture) they started looking. It's not a guarantee, but it's worth honestly examining why you were job searching in the first place before deciding.
Is it unethical to use a job offer just to get a raise from my current employer?
Doing this as a calculated bluff with no intention of ever leaving carries real relationship risk if it becomes clear later, and can also feel dishonest depending on how you view your obligations. It's more sustainable to negotiate raises based on your actual value and market data, and let a genuine offer be a genuine decision point, not manufactured leverage.

Before your next interview, it helps to have the fundamentals down. Our complete guide to preparing for a job interview covers the basics, and the STAR method is a reliable way to structure almost any answer under pressure.

Try an AI mock interview free
A real voice interviewer that questions you, drills into weak spots, and scores your answers, grounded in your actual CV and the job description.
Try a Mock Interview Free