Why interviewers ask this

This question tests whether you can disagree constructively and professionally with someone senior to you, rather than either staying silent when you have genuine, valuable input or becoming confrontational. Interviewers are specifically looking for respectful, evidence-based pushback, not conflict avoidance or insubordination.

Choosing the right example

Pick a genuine, moderate disagreement about a real decision or approach, ideally one where you raised a reasoned concern respectfully and the outcome, whether your view prevailed or not, was handled professionally by both parties. Avoid an example that makes the manager sound clearly unreasonable, since this can raise doubts about your judgement or the environment.

How to structure your answer

Briefly explain the disagreement and your reasoning, describe how you raised it respectfully and with supporting evidence, and close honestly with the outcome, including how you handled it professionally if your manager ultimately did not agree with your view.

Get real-time help in your next interview
Live Interview Help listens to your interview and surfaces personalised answers in real time. Free 20-minute trial on Google Meet, Teams, and Zoom.
Install Free on Chrome
Check your CV against the job description first
Free AI-powered CV Match Check scores your CV against any job description: missing keywords, weak impact metrics, and ATS parsing risk, before you even apply.
Check My CV Free

Frequently asked questions

What if my manager ultimately did not agree with me?
This is a genuinely fine outcome to describe, as long as you show you raised your view respectfully and then supported the final decision professionally, since interviewers are assessing how you handle disagreement, not whether you always win it.
Should I avoid this question if I have never disagreed with a manager?
A moderate, genuine example is preferable to claiming you have never disagreed at all, since the latter can read as either limited experience or an unwillingness to raise concerns, both of which are mild yellow flags to interviewers.

Before your next interview, it helps to have the fundamentals down. Our complete guide to preparing for a job interview covers the basics, and the STAR method is a reliable way to structure almost any answer under pressure.

Try an AI mock interview free
A real voice interviewer that questions you, drills into weak spots, and scores your answers, grounded in your actual CV and the job description.
Try a Mock Interview Free